Shelly i3 mit Tasmota: Ghost Switching

ALanger

Hallo zusammen,

ich habe auf meine Shelly i3s Tasmota 9.4.0.3 installiert und dieses Template aus der Tasmota-DB verwendet. SwitchDebounce steht auf 50. Vor dem Shelly (in der gleichen Dose) sitzt ein Dreifachtaster, der L auf jeweils I1-I3 schaltet. Funktioniert auch alles wunderbar, leider sehe ich jedoch relativ viel Ghost Switching. Um das Beispiel zu verdeutlichen und zu analysieren, habe ich den Shelly so konfiguriert:

Code

Rule1
    ON system#boot DO var1 0 ENDON
    ON Switch1#state=2 DO add1 1 ENDON
Rule1 1
SetOption114 1
SwitchMode1 3
SwitchMode2 3
SwitchMode3 3
SwitchTopic 0

Und der Auszug aus der Console von heute Nacht:

Code

21:26:48.354 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:22:46.195 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:23:04.457 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:34:39.889 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:40:00.729 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:40:08.455 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:41:19.084 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:41:47.597 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:50:17.701 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:50:19.602 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:51:15.583 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:51:30.461 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:52:15.578 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:52:31.301 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:52:41.872 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:53:15.432 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:53:25.716 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:53:59.794 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
01:56:19.681 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:04:02.473 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:05:20.520 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:05:31.034 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:06:28.667 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:06:28.910 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:08:18.193 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:08:23.425 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:08:25.829 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:08:28.471 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:08:28.717 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:09:59.752 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:10:05.172 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:10:10.899 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:10:11.339 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:12:02.253 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:12:04.829 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:16:04.438 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:16:05.423 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:17:33.866 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:19:17.388 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:19:20.769 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:19:21.715 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:19:23.224 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:21:18.180 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:22:05.504 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:22:31.526 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:29:42.180 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:32:00.434 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:32:05.966 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:33:06.230 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:33:08.754 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:33:48.657 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:34:20.189 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:37:18.549 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:38:50.224 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:41:30.676 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:41:35.002 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:41:37.608 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:42:09.531 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:42:20.098 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:42:22.605 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:43:38.315 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:43:58.429 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:00.650 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:01.003 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:17.116 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:20.250 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:21.666 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:44:47.111 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:45:39.633 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:46:44.590 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:46:47.330 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:47:03.272 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:48:59.261 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:50:26.300 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:53:26.924 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:54:44.877 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
02:55:19.296 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
[... unzählige weitere ...]
04:35:31.349 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
04:35:41.309 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
04:35:45.759 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
04:36:09.409 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
04:36:12.044 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
04:58:40.493 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:03:13.313 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:04:04.100 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:04:14.877 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:04:25.602 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:05:12.136 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:07:06.670 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:07:12.272 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:08:36.396 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:08:53.952 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:30.374 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:33.349 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:35.911 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:36.402 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:41.295 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:46.627 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:09:48.959 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"
05:24:26.896 RUL: SWITCH1#STATE=2 performs "add1 1"

Alles anzeigen

Die Netzwerkverbindung bleibt dabei stabil, der Shelly hat auch nicht neugestartet o.ä.

Ich habe bereits versucht, die SwitchDebounce auf höhere, sogar unpraktikable Werte zu stellen (z.B. 500ms). Das Ghostswitching tritt dann seltener auf, aber trotzdem noch mehrfach am Tag.

Hat jemand eine Idee, was man noch dagegen tun könnte? Ich habe noch 50 weitere Shellys (Shelly 1, Shelly 2.5 und Shelly Dimmer 2) im Haus, und nur die i3s haben das Problem mit dem Ghostswitching.

Ich bin nahedran, die i3s durch 2x 2.5 zu tauschen

ALanger

Update: Hab jetzt wieder die Original-Firmware aufgespielt, und damit ist das Ghost Switching noch schlimmer, offenbar schafft Tasmota es besser, diese zu erkennen.

Laut Logfiles betätigt sich der Schalter nachts 800x von selbst.

HoerMirAuf

Hi.

Hast Du das teil an einem MQTT Server angemeldet?